
Toolkit: Problem Investigation Worksheet and 5W1H Question Guide
Toolkit 2 of 10 · Problem Investigation Worksheet and 5W1H Question Guide · Based on Chapter 4 (§4.1–4.6) of Dr. Tahseen Al Doori's Troubleshooting Essentials, University Edition (2026). The 5W1H questions and problem statement template are the author's; the worksheet layout is the course's.
How to use this sheet
Use this worksheet during Step 1: Identify the problem, before you form any theory. Work through Part 1 with the user, gather the evidence in Part 2, then combine everything into the problem statement in Part 3. Do not attempt a fix until you can write that statement clearly. Keep the completed sheet with your problem log.
Interview tips: listen fully and acknowledge the impact on the user; avoid jargon; ask open questions first ("What were you doing when it happened?"), then closed questions to confirm details ("Did you see an error message?"); ask the user to demonstrate the problem where possible. Treat any diagnosis the user offers as a theory to test, not a fact.
Part 1 — The 5W1H questions
| Question | What to ask | Prompts | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| What | What exactly happens? What should happen instead? | Exact symptom; expected behaviour; any error text | |
| When | When did it start? Always or sometimes? | Date and time first noticed; time of day; how often | |
| Where | Which device, room, site, network or application? | Device name; location; wired or Wi-Fi; one application or all | |
| Who | Who is affected: one person, a team, everyone? | Other users on the same device or system; other sites | |
| Which | Which changes happened just before? | Updates, installations, new hardware, moved equipment, password changes, power interruptions, new staff | |
| How | How is it triggered? Can it be repeated? | Steps to reproduce; same device and account; conditions |
When the user says "nothing changed"
Ask specific questions instead. Tick each one asked and note the answer.
| ✓ | Question | Answer |
|---|---|---|
| ☐ | Was anything installed or updated? | |
| ☐ | Was the device moved or cleaned? | |
| ☐ | Did the power go off? | |
| ☐ | Has anyone else used it? | |
| ☐ | Has a password been changed recently? | |
| ☐ | Has anything new been connected? |
Part 2 — Evidence collected
| Evidence type | What to record | Recorded |
|---|---|---|
| Exact error messages | Word for word, with any code; screenshot or photograph | |
| Physical symptoms | Indicator lights, beep codes, sounds, smells, heat, vibration | |
| Logs and history | Event log entries at the time of the fault; update history; recent installations | |
| Scope | One user or many; one device or all; one site or every site | |
| Recent changes | Anything listed under Which | |
| Baseline comparison | How the system normally looks and performs; differences from an identical working system |
Part 3 — Reproduction and intermittent faults
| Item | Entry |
|---|---|
| Can the fault be reproduced on demand? (yes / no) | |
| Steps used to reproduce it | |
| If not reproducible: occurrence log started? (date) |
Occurrence log (use for intermittent faults; a pattern usually appears over several occurrences):
| # | Date | Time | Activity at the time | Conditions (power, network, location, temperature, other users) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| 3 | ||||
| 4 | ||||
| 5 | ||||
| 6 |
Part 4 — The problem statement
Combine your answers into one or two sentences that are specific, factual and testable. The book's template:
Since [when], [who] cannot [what] on [where]. It happens [always / intermittently] when [how]. The most recent change was [which]. The error shown is "[exact message]".
| Template slot | Your entry |
|---|---|
| Since [when] | |
| [who] | |
| cannot [what] | |
| on [where] | |
| It happens [always / intermittently] | |
| when [how] | |
| The most recent change was [which] | |
| The error shown is "[exact message]" |
Final problem statement:
Self-check: Does the statement contain a guess presented as fact? If so, remove it: causes belong in Step 2.
Sources
- Dr. Tahseen Al Doori — Troubleshooting Essentials, University Edition (2026), §2.3 (practitioner tip), §4.1–4.6
